Re: Technical Observations on SATAN: Issue: VMS and TCP/IP

Robert A. Pickering Jr. (pickerin@phoenix.sas.muohio.edu)
Fri, 7 Apr 1995 07:26:39 -0400 (EDT)

We Ran SATAN here against several of our Unix machines, all passed.  I 
then tried it agains one of our AXP/VMS workstations running Multinet.

It crashed.

After the machine came back up we tried it again.

It passed fine.

I did Heavy tests both times.  At first glance it appears that the AXP
just ran out of memory.

-Rob



On Fri, 7 Apr 1995, Tim Scanlon wrote:

> Erik Lindquist wrote:
> |For some reason when I test SATAN against VMS systems running either UCX or
> |Wollongong TCP/IP stacks the systems crash.
> 
> |This seems to be true for the heavy test only.  Other potentially
> |coincidental events include:
> |	1.  First test on a given node; when system reboots and a test
> |	    is again performed a successful test seems to be made.
> |	2.  The first test uses the FQDN and the second test uses the
> |	    IP address.
> 
> |I have no idea where to look? The crash logs do not reveal anything helpful.
> |A message coming from SATAN says:
> |	bin/udp_scan: are we talking to a dead host or network?
> 
> I do some admin stuff at GMU, and while one of the other admin's here
> was running it against our subnet we encountered a crash. We've got
> a Paragon, and on the heavy scan it crashed during the test. We havn't
> isolated why yet, but suspect that it was becasue it was being hammered
> quite fast. This was after the "light & med" tests hasd passed. That
> machine is fairly tight, so it wasn't a matter of there being alot
> of ports open or anything... Anyway it didn't happen again, and we
> really ~obviously~ arn't looking to replicate it, particlularly on
> this machine, but I'd be interested to hear of any similar stuff
> from other folks.
> 
> -tfs
> 
> 
> ________________________________________________________________
> tfs@vampire.science.gmu.edu (NeXTmail, MIME)  Tim Scanlon
> George Mason University     (PGP key avail.)  Public Affairs
> I speak for myself, but often claim demonic posession
> 

--
Robert A. Pickering Jr.                           UNIX Software Specialist
Miami Computing and Information Services          pickerin@muohio.edu

"Most people, if they counted how many people swam across the river, would
never think about building bridges."  - Ronald Altman